White Gold Rolex Submariner: Smurf 116619LB vs Cookie Monster 126619LB

The Rolex Submariner Smurf is the 116619LB, an 18k white gold Submariner Date with a blue dial and a blue Cerachrom bezel. Rolex discontinued it in 2020 and replaced it with the 126619LB, a 41mm white gold Submariner with a black dial and the same blue bezel, known as the Cookie Monster. Rolex has since dropped the 126619LB from its 2026 catalogue too, so both watches now come from the pre-owned market.

What is the Rolex Smurf 116619LB?

The Smurf is the white gold Submariner with a blue dial and blue ceramic bezel, reference 116619LB. The "LB" stands for lunette bleue, the blue bezel. It is a 40mm Submariner Date in 18k white gold on a matching Oyster bracelet with a blue dial that matches the bezel.

The nickname comes from the all-blue look, which recalls the cartoon characters. Because the case and bracelet are white gold rather than steel, the watch reads as a quiet, cool-toned luxury piece instead of a tool watch. It is no longer made, so supply is whatever already exists.

What is the Rolex Cookie Monster 126619LB?

The Cookie Monster is the 2020 white gold Submariner successor, reference 126619LB, with a black dial and a blue Cerachrom bezel. It grew to a 41mm case and moved to the newer caliber 3235. The name plays on the blue and black pairing.

It is the sensible choice for a buyer who wants a white gold Submariner with the modern movement and case proportions. The black dial also makes it the more versatile of the two on a daily basis, and because it is the newer reference, later examples tend to be in fresher condition.

Smurf vs Cookie Monster: what actually changed?

The dial colour is the headline change, but the case size, movement and bracelet all moved with the generation. The table below sticks to manufacturer-level facts and leaves out pricing.

Which is better, the Smurf or the Cookie Monster?

Neither is objectively better; the Smurf wins on character and scarcity, the Cookie Monster wins on specification and everyday ease. If you want the all-blue statement and accept a 40mm case and the older movement, the Smurf is the one. If you want the larger case, the longer power reserve and a dial that works with anything, the Cookie Monster is the stronger daily wearer.

Buyers who like the idea of a blue Submariner but find a full white gold watch too much sometimes compare both against the two-tone and yellow gold blue-dial Submariners. Those are different watches with a different personality, so it is worth seeing them side by side before you decide.

How did the bracelet and case change?

The 126619LB gained a slightly larger case and a reworked Oyster bracelet with more substantial links, which gives it a bolder presence on the wrist than the 116619LB. The clasp architecture is the same family, with the Oysterlock safety catch and an extension for fitting over a wetsuit. Handle both in person if you can, because the 40mm and 41mm cases wear differently depending on wrist size.

How much do white gold Submariners cost?

White gold Submariners sit well above their steel siblings, and the Smurf and Cookie Monster both trade in roughly the mid five figures on the pre-owned market. Condition, year, box and papers and whether the watch has been polished move the number more than the nickname does. For comparison, see the from-prices on the full Rolex Submariner range and the yellow gold Submariner models.

What should you verify when sourcing a white gold Submariner?

Verify the reference, serial, dial, bezel and service history against the paperwork before any money moves. White gold is expensive to get wrong, so use this short list:

• The reference and serial engraving on the case match the papers and the production era of the watch.
• The dial print, the lume plots and the date magnifier look correct under strong light, and the blue of a Smurf dial matches the bezel the way it should.
• The case and bracelet are not over-polished; white gold shows buffing as softened lugs and lost bevels.
• The bracelet has not stretched and the clasp closes crisply.
• Box, warranty card and any service invoices are included, or the gap is priced in.

Every watch Bizak & Co. sources is a specific unit, confirmed before you commit. We do not hold stock, so we ask the questions up front and show you the photographs of the exact watch.

Smurf and Cookie Monster FAQ

Which is the Smurf, the 116619LB or the 126619LB?

The Smurf is the 116619LB: an 18k white gold Submariner Date with a blue dial and a blue Cerachrom bezel, made until 2020. The 126619LB that replaced it has a black dial with the same blue bezel, and collectors call it the Cookie Monster.

Are the Smurf and Cookie Monster discontinued?

Yes. Rolex replaced the 116619LB with the 126619LB in 2020 and no longer lists the 126619LB either, so both now come from the pre-owned market rather than from current production.

Is the Cookie Monster bigger than the Smurf?

Yes. The 126619LB has a 41mm case against 40mm on the 116619LB, and it carries the newer caliber 3235 with a longer power reserve.

What should I check before buying a white gold Submariner?

Confirm the reference engraving and serial match the watch and papers, look at case and bracelet wear for over-polishing, check the dial and bezel for correct printing and colour, and ask for clear photographs of the clasp and rehaut. Service history helps on any pre-owned unit.

Can Bizak & Co. source a Smurf or a Cookie Monster?

Yes. Bizak & Co. is a sourcing desk, not an authorised Rolex retailer. We find a specific watch on request and confirm the unit, photographs and final price before you commit.

Related reading: Rolex nicknames explained.

Get your Rolex sourced

Tell us which watch you want (Smurf or Cookie Monster), whether you want unworn or worn, your box-and-papers requirements, and your budget and timing, through our sourcing enquiry form. We confirm the specific watch, photographs and final price before you commit, so you can arrange financing against a real target.